Bev Murray Neighborhoods Home Buying

547 N Shore Dr is a historically recognized Mediterranean Revival home for sale in Sarasota’s sought-after Indian Beach Sapphire Shores neighborhood. Built in 1928 during Sarasota’s early Ringling-era growth, this restored residence offers 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms in the main home, along with a detached 1-bedroom, 1-bath guest house — all set on an oversized 0.40-acre double lot just moments from Sarasota Bay.

Located west of the Trail, the property is positioned outside the flood zone and at approximately 15 feet of elevation (per MLS), offering both historic character and practical advantages.

The home’s layout unfolds around private courtyard-style living, where interior spaces transition naturally to the covered lanai and screened pool area — a design approach characteristic of Mediterranean Revival architecture in Florida’s early growth years.

Historically Designated Mediterranean Revival Home in Sarasota, FL

Recognized with a historic designation plaque, this residence reflects the Mediterranean Revival style that shaped much of Sarasota’s early architectural identity. The stucco façade, arched openings, clay tile detailing, and traditional proportions remain intact, preserving the integrity of the original design.

As one of a limited number of early homes in Sapphire Shores, the property represents a meaningful piece of Sarasota’s architectural history.

Mediterranean Revival Architecture at 547 N Shore Dr Sarasota

The approach begins with a reclaimed brick circular driveway framed by mature landscaping. An arched entry and decorative tile accents introduce the home’s Mediterranean character before you step inside.

Interior spaces feature exposed wood beams, arched transitions between rooms, and a central fireplace that anchors the living area. The architectural details feel original and intentional — not recreated — offering a sense of authenticity that defines historic homes of this era.

2017 Renovation and Modern Updates in This Historic Sarasota Home

The current owners completed an extensive renovation in 2017 that enhanced functionality while respecting the home’s architectural roots:

• Expanded kitchen layout
• Butler’s pantry and laundry room addition
• New roof
• Updated plumbing and electrical systems
• Renovated bathrooms

The kitchen integrates historic texture with contemporary convenience, incorporating exposed brick elements, artisan tile, custom cabinetry, and high-end appliances beneath a statement hood. The result is a space designed for daily living and entertaining without compromising the home’s character.

Updated baths maintain stylistic continuity through thoughtful material choices while delivering modern comfort.

Outdoor Living and Private Pool Courtyard at 547 N Shore Dr

Approximately 2,000 square feet of outdoor living space was added as part of the renovation, creating a seamless extension of the home.

A Spanish-inspired covered lanai provides dedicated areas for dining, lounging, and gathering. Architectural arches and wood beam detailing continue the Mediterranean theme outdoors.

Beyond the lanai, a pool deck with panoramic screening is framed by lush landscaping, offering privacy and usable outdoor space throughout the year.

The 0.40-acre double lot also accommodates curated garden beds and mature plantings, contributing to the property’s sense of space and tranquility.

Main Residence and Detached Guest House in Indian Beach Sarasota

The primary residence includes three bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, and a sunroom/den. The detached 1-bedroom, 1-bath guest house offers additional flexibility for visitors, extended stays, or private workspace.

A two-car garage, currently used as a workshop/workout area, can be converted back to traditional garage use if desired.

Indian Beach Sapphire Shores Real Estate and Homes for Sale

Indian Beach Sapphire Shores is one of Sarasota’s most established historic neighborhoods, located between U.S. 41 and Sarasota Bay just south of The Ringling Museum. Known for its tree-lined streets and architectural diversity, the area features a mix of Mediterranean Revival, mid-century, and contemporary homes.

Residents enjoy proximity to locations around Sarasota:

• The Ringling Museum and Asolo Theatre
• Ringling College of Art and Design
• New College of Florida
• Downtown Sarasota
• Lido Beach and St. Armands Circle

From 547 N Shore Dr, wide residential streets lead toward a neighborhood bayfront park where residents gather for sunset views and waterfront recreation.

Historic Home for Sale in Sarasota’s Museum Area (West of the Trail)

Opportunities to acquire a historically recognized Mediterranean Revival residence in Sarasota’s Museum Area are limited. With its double lot, preserved architectural details, and documented renovation, this property offers a combination of historic character and modern updates that is increasingly difficult to find.

For buyers seeking a historic home in Indian Beach Sapphire Shores, 547 N Shore Dr presents a rare offering within one of Sarasota’s most culturally significant districts.

Schedule a Private Showing – 547 N Shore Dr, Sarasota FL 34234

To experience this property in person, contact:
Bev MurrayBerkshire Hathaway HomeServices Florida Realty
(941) 724-4995